Sign in
Explore Diverse Guest Blogging Opportunities on CSMIndustry.de
Your Position: Home - Ventilation Fans - twin-screw vs roots vs centrifugal vs turbo
Guest Posts

twin-screw vs roots vs centrifugal vs turbo

Sep. 09, 2024

twin-screw vs roots vs centrifugal vs turbo

Early WRXes were notorious for having really laggy turbo systems, primarily due to restrictive exhausts featuring multiple catalytic converters, and even a cat positioned before the turbo—definitely a poor choice for performance responsiveness. While I've noticed improvements in later models, the extent of this enhancement remains uncertain.

If you require more details, kindly visit our website.

Most original equipment manufacturer (OEM) turbos tend to be relatively small, specifically designed to produce significant torque at lower RPMs while minimizing lag. For instance, my previous B5 S4, equipped with a 2.7L engine and twin KKK K03 turbochargers, achieved peak torque at around a certain RPM, which noticeably dwindled above a specific threshold (with a redline of too high). The subtle whooshing sound made it almost imperceptible that the car was turbocharged, and it notably outperformed the naturally aspirated 4.2L V8 in the B6 S4 that later replaced it, particularly in low-end torque delivery.

Aftermarket turbo kits often feature larger sizes compared to OEM versions. The K03 turbos max out around 180-200 crank horsepower each, whereas the GT model mentioned by Keith—one of the smallest options in the aftermarket—can support approximately 250 horsepower. In my Miata, the GT turbo is rated at 300 and can transition from vacuum to full boost in less than half a second while driving on the freeway. During autox events, in 2nd or 3rd gear, it reaches full boost almost instantaneously as your foot hits the accelerator.

Another critical distinction among forced induction systems is their altitude response. Positive displacement superchargers (and most traditional centrifugal models) behave similarly to naturally aspirated engines; as altitude increases and ambient pressure decreases, the torque curve proportionally drops but maintains its original shape. On the other hand, turbocharged vehicles tend to spin their turbos faster to compensate for altitude losses. Elevating altitude typically raises the boost threshold (the minimum RPM required for full boost) while introducing increased lag; however, peak power loss is significantly less than in supercharged or naturally aspirated arrangements. Depending on the vehicle's MAP-referenced electric boost control and turboheadroom, it may not experience a decline in peak power at all.

A notable challenge I've faced with turbos during autox events is the shifting torque at certain RPM/TPS points as boost levels rise. This dynamic can complicate corner exit performance compared to naturally aspirated or supercharged vehicles, yet it is not an insurmountable issue.

Twin Screw Vs Roots Vs Centrifugal Supercharger

There are many straightforward methods to enhance your vehicle's horsepower, including upgrading the intake system, reprogramming the Electronic Control Unit, or replacing the exhaust system with a more free-flowing variant. Yet, there is a limit to what these modifications can achieve. For those with a genuine need for speed, incorporating a turbocharger or supercharger for forced induction is the solution, capable of adding over 100 horsepower to your engine—transforming even the most mundane engine into an exhilarating driving experience.

If you are looking for more details, kindly visit Benyuan.

Advertisement

The various options—twin screw, Roots, and centrifugal superchargers—come with their own advantages and disadvantages. Our goal isn't to settle the supercharger versus turbocharger debate here; rather, we aim to assist those opting for a supercharger by guiding them in selecting the best option among these three types. All three serve the same purpose—boosting engine power—but they operate in distinct ways, each offering unique benefits and drawbacks that you should consider before making a commitment.

With sufficient time and finances, testing each supercharger type on your engine could yield valuable insights, though most people do not have that luxury. Therefore, we've compiled a concise overview and comparison of all three supercharger types to facilitate your decision-making process.

Contact us to discuss your requirements for a Twin Screw Roots Blower. Our knowledgeable sales team is available to assist you in identifying the options that best align with your needs.

  • 25
  • 0
  • 0
Comments

0 of 2000 characters used

All Comments (0)