10 Top Rated Eye Creams With Natural Ingredients (2024)

10 Top Rated Eye Creams With Natural Ingredients (2024)

The Good Trade editors recommend products that have been thoroughly researched, tested, and genuinely loved. Discover more about our methodology and business model here.

For further information, please visit our website.

After trying numerous clean eye creams, here are my top selections with organic ingredients that are hydrating, safe, and reasonably priced.

Our eyes can be the first to reveal signs of fatigue, dehydration, or changes in the seasons. Issues like puffiness, dark circles, and fine lines can affect our appearance. Fortunately, there is hope for restoring the under-eye skin through the use of effective eye creams.

We have compiled a list of ten excellent organic eye creams and gels that are sure to rejuvenate your eyes. Infused with organic ingredients such as rosehip oil, coffee extract, aloe, squalane, and algae, these products hydrate your skin naturally and safely.

Why opt for natural, nontoxic eye cream?

Considering the sensitive nature of the skin around our eyes, it can easily display signs of stress from factors like lack of sleep or dehydration. This delicate skin may also react more severely to harsh skincare components, prompting us to choose brands that prioritize natural ingredients in their formulations.

It is important to note that effective eye creams often blend the qualities of a serum with those of a moisturizer, simultaneously hydrating and delivering active components. While not everyone needs an eye cream in their skincare regimen (besides the essential SPF), they can be beneficial for targeting specific issues like dark circles or fine lines, providing much-needed nourishment.

Our methodology and criteria:

To evaluate the eye creams mentioned below, I applied them as part of my daily routine—after serum and before moisturizer—on multiple occasions, with some even tested for several months. Typically, I would use no more than a pea-sized amount between both eyes. For brightening creams, I applied them in the morning, while nourishing formulations were left to work overnight. As seen in the reviews below, some products excel for both day and night use.

A bit about my skincare journey: I have combination and acne-prone skin, and the under-eye area can switch between oily and dry based on my habits or environmental conditions. I often notice slight darkness and inflammation in the morning after insufficient sleep, with my primary concern being fine lines that become more pronounced when my skin is dehydrated.

We selected all the eye creams on this list based on specific criteria, conducting regular testing and updates to include new products that fit our standards:

• HYDRATING | The most critical aspect for addressing under-eye concerns is hydration! Well-hydrated skin reduces the look of fine lines and dark circles.
• NONTOXIC | Each brand listed below has impressive natural and non-toxic credentials, supported by various third-party certifications such as EWG verification and cruelty-free status.
• AFFORDABLE | We’ve included a range of eye creams at various price points to meet diverse budgets.

Looking for lighter alternatives to eye creams? Consider natural under-eye patches! While rejuvenating your eyes, treat the rest of your face with these organic skincare brands and face moisturizers.

Best Overall | Most Affordable | Best for Sensitive Skin

1. Follain

Best For | Everyday staple
Natural & Organic Ingredients | Rose water, squalane, bakuchiol
Price | $38 ($76/oz)

I first reviewed this eye cream from Follain a few months ago, and it was so impressive that it's remained a staple in my routine. After using it for a few weeks, I've noticed a brightening effect under my eyes with a lovely creamy gel texture complemented by a light floral scent from the rose water. Its brightening effect likely stems from caffeine, which helps reduce puffiness and lighten the area. The cream contains hydrating squalane and collagen-boosting bakuchiol, serving as a gentler alternative to retinol, making it suitable for both day and night use. Follain is widely recognized for its vegan and cruelty-free skincare at accessible price points, and I have yet to be disappointed by their offerings.

2. Tata Harper

Best For | Luxury option
Natural & Organic Ingredients | Centella asiatica, lactobacillus ferment, calendula extract, green tea extract
Price | $130 ($260/oz)

The most expensive product on our list, the Tata Harper Restorative Eye Cream is designed to impress. Its silky texture absorbs effortlessly, and after using it overnight, I noticed significantly fewer fine lines in the morning. The formulation boasts 32 botanicals that work in synergy to rejuvenate the eye area, ideal for both daytime and nighttime use. Tata Harper prides itself on sustainable practices by using hand-selected raw ingredients and chic refillable glass packaging.

3. Ilia

Best For | Light-reflecting particles
Natural & Organic Ingredients | Avocado oil, jojoba oil esters, squalane
Price | $46 ($92/oz)

Ilia's Bright Start Retinol Alternative Eye Cream combines skincare and makeup, featuring subtle light-reflecting particles that visibly brighten the under-eye area. It contains potent ingredients such as caffeine, squalane, and peptides that nourish the skin while remaining smoothly under makeup. The innovative ceramic tip offers a cooling massage, enhancing the product's de-puffing effect, making it perfect for those mornings when you need an extra boost.

4. cocokind

Best For | Most affordable
Natural & Organic Ingredients | Hibiscus flower acids, oat extract
Price | $19 ($38/oz)

cocokind is a fan favorite here at The Good Trade, known for its ethical skincare models and transparency in ingredients. Their revitalizing eye cream incorporates hibiscus flower acids, which provide gentle exfoliation, and oat extract, which aids in moisture retention for a refreshing and plumping effect. It features a gel-like consistency and has a metal applicator tip that provides a soothing cooling sensation, particularly in the mornings.

5. True Botanicals

Best For | Mature skin
Natural & Organic Ingredients | Green tea extract, mango seed butter, lactobacillus ferment, coffee seed extract
Price | $80 ($160/oz)

True Botanicals' Resurrection Radiance Eye Cream is a nourishing, thicker option ideal for hydration. Its buttery texture glides smoothly, further enhanced by a pleasant herbal aroma. Perfect for those with dry skin, clinical studies have shown significant improvements in hydration, fine lines, and wrinkles within six weeks of use, catering well to sensitive skin types.

6. 100% Pure

Best For | Best price per ounce
Natural & Organic Ingredients | Green tea extract, coffee extract, rosehip oil, aloe
Price | $29 ($29/oz)

Looking for an affordable yet effective option? The Coffee Bean Caffeine Eye Cream from 100% Pure beautifully balances quality and affordability. I found it soothing after an early morning wakeup, thanks to its gel/cream texture and subtle sweetness. Packed with caffeine and antioxidants, clinical studies confirm a significant reduction in puffiness and overall improvement in skin hydration after consistent use.

7. Ursa Major

Best For | Dry skin
Natural & Organic Ingredients | Green tea, shea butter, rosehip oil, mushroom extract
Price | $56 ($112/oz)

This eye cream boasts a rich and buttery formulation that provides deep hydration, making it ideal for night use. Combining botanicals and peptides, it enhances skin elasticity while addressing hyperpigmentation. Made in Vermont, Ursa Major ensures sustainable practices, including using recyclable packaging in their products.

8. Juice Beauty

Best For | Morning and night use
Natural & Organic Ingredients | Jojoba oil, shea butter, apple juice, aloe
Price | $50 ($100/oz)

Juice Beauty's Stem Cellular Anti-Wrinkle Eye Treatment is effective enough to significantly reduce fine lines overnight. Its base formula involves apple juice combined with fruit stem cells and vital vitamins to enhance overall effectiveness. Users have reported clinical improvements in skin brightness and hydration within two weeks of use.

9. Osea

Best For | Serum-like consistency
Natural & Organic Ingredients | Quinoa extract, gardenia extract, honeysuckle extract
Price | $58 ($100/oz)

Osea’s Ocean Eyes is unique as an eye serum, offering refreshing hydration in a liquid form that revitalizes tired eyes. Clinical studies reveal its effectiveness in minimizing puffiness and dark circles over four weeks of use, and its rollerball applicator ensures convenient application.

10. Three Ships

Best For | Gentle formulation
Natural & Organic Ingredients | Squalane, acerola cherry extract, shea butter
Price | $32 ($64/oz)

Three Ships' First Light eye cream is perfect for those with sensitivities or conditions like eczema, crafted with a gentle approach. It's suitable for morning use, featuring lightweight hydration without any oily residue and enhanced with a delightful ceramic applicator for a refreshing sensation.

Natalie Gale is a Contributing Editor at The Good Trade, based in Boston. She writes about art, food, and sustainability. Outside of writing, she enjoys visiting farmers' markets, baking, sewing, or planning her next Halloween costume. Connect with her on Instagram!

For more information, please visit drplant anti wrinkle eye cream.